|
"St. Catherine's Clock," the sequence
about Dublin experience in the 12th Peppercanister
pamphlet, as David Kellogg mentioned, is "a
tapestry of reflexivity, laced and layered with recycled bits of
earlier poems" (163). Yet this poem is explicitly and
assuredly more than a tapestry of his earlier poems, but rather
flexibly blends tiers of historical narratives, time and space
individually and collectively. Unlike 'Nightwalker,' the speaker in
"St. Catherine's Clock" is less conscious and anxious about changing
from the metaphorical representation of physical body, psychological
subject to cultural identity in the development of poetic composition.
On the contrary, the process of subjectivity formation is socially
situated and constructed in relation to politics, to effects on power
structure, and to historiography. "St. Catherine's Clock" eradicates
the visible borderline or radical breach among stages of self-formation
in the poetic composition and the poet's autobiography, and further
paradoxically marks particular time and space through the embedded
clock on St. Catherine's Church. The poem counteracts the 'clock' time
in the poem and moves freely in the course of temporality and
historicity. Moreover, unlike "Butcher's Dozen," the poet's
interpretations of violence, politics and history are more implicit,
discreet and metaphorical in the sequence of temporality and spatiality
of Dublin, particularly in the area of St. Catherine's Parish. "St.
Catherine's Clock" not only forms Kinsella's poetics of
historiography that embodies the socio-political process
of subjectivity formation and projects the self-reflexive speaker in
the poetic composition, but also elaborately conflates multiple
perspectives of historical narratives, visual representation of
historical-political events in engravings, and fragmentary
memories of childhood and family in the poet's Dublin
experience. Furthermore, this poetic walking poem
depicts the movement to-and-fro the present and the past in the
multiple perspectives of narratives, and also generates the process of
writing and revising in the poetic structure of time and the space of
history, society, and politics.
For the structure and arrangement,
"St. Catherine's Clock" roughly contains seven sections in accordance
with Kinsella's framework of temporality in
historical context and particular temporal/spatial markers in
the poem. The poet organizes a nearly three-hour journey walk across
centre Dublin from Thomas Street, Basin Lane, Grand Canal Place, and
Francis Street. (See figure 1-3, maps of
Dublin in appendix 2) Through this walk, the poet offers a
multiple layered experience of Dublin city and obviously attempts to
retrieve the recollection from the public history and private memoir.
This walk introduces the poet's deployment of temporality-the
juxtaposition of or the interval between the present and the past in
the context of space. In other words, the concept of time and space in
this poem are mixed and reconstructed in terms of poetics. Meanwhile,
Kinsella characterizes and allocates his speaking subject as a walker
in the trajectory of poetic discourse with his sophisticated
apprehension and perception of urban experience by process of
depicting, narrating, and witnessing the moments. Like the other three
volumes of the Peppercanister poems in the 1980's, "St. Catherine's
Clock," as Brian John mentions, continues Kinsella's personal and
psychic exploration from Notes from the Land of the Dead,
which leads the poet's perceptions and concerns about the Jungian myth
and archetypical lands of the dead in the perspective of 'psychic
geography.' From this geographic perception of the past, this poem,
certainly a contextualization of Dublin by using the emblem of the
clock on the church, explicates the multiple-layered narrative of
history, memories and time in the trajectory of urban walking
in-between the past and the present in an endless to-and-fro movement
of across time and space within the process of poetic formation. The
emblem of St. Catherine's Clock metaphorically conducts the course of
history in the poem and intentionally establishes the movements of time
and space in the trajectory of history, politics and subjectivity
formation in the process of writing and revising the poetic composition.
TOP
|
|
Introduction
'1938,' the fourth sequence in "St.
Catherine's Clock," represents the individual experiences of childhood
and recollections of family, respectively on domestic life and frolics
in the wilderness of urban space. From these two perspectives, this
sequence in general goes through details of everyday life scenes,
relations of family, excursions in streets and suburbs, a temporary
intermezzo at the Grand Canal Place,
and eventually the initiation of self-consciousness through a process
of identification in time and space. Like browsing through collections
of family photographs, these pictures of childhood and family life
depict the nostalgic days of the early Irish Republic, reminiscences of
family history, and affiliations with geographic locations, places or
sites in the town of Dublin. Following his view of family photographs,
the poet delineates his own pictorial representation of Dublin streets
in the 1930's and attempts to reassembe fragments of memories, to
reconstruct and to authenticate the autobiographical historicity in the
context of the turning point of the Irish Republic as well as the
poet's walk at the second hour "in the terminus harbour" (BF80). In
addition, this retrospection of personal experience embodies the
presence of subjectivity or the speaking subject in the process of
walking through old places and memories.
TOP
Family and Childhood in Retrospective
Memories.
Pictures of family and childhood life attempt to retrieve the personal
account of history and to recollect fragments of the lost past in 'the
pictorial and descriptive' by autobiographical writing. At first,
"1938" conveys a series of photographic snapshots in the grandmother's
shop, the detailed descriptive scenes of everyday life in the account
of family history. The poet approaches the shop-family house and then
closely introduces the interior arrangement of this shop and a
preliminary impression of the grandmother and her world. In the eyes of
the poet, nostalgic objects on the shelf animate collections of family
photographs in fragments of sequential memories, experiences, and
impressions.
Two
red-and black matched silky-decorated
tin boxes out of India
fit beside each other behind her
up on the tea shelf, behind her head.
The
shoulder of the black iron-flowered
weighing-scales on the counter
balance, embossed, across the socket-top of the stand.
The brass plates hang, equal, in their chains.
Round ounce weights
and multiples and little
black fractions nestle
on one another against the base (BF74)
First,
Indian tin boxes of tea on the shelf are regularly behind grandmother.
Then "iron-flowered" weighing scales with brass plates still stand on
the counter. These first two snapshots of the shop outline
grandmother's place in order and detail. Tea boxes clearly signify the
necessity of material life in the social context. However, in the
cultural context the image of an Indian tin box sophisticatedly brings
in a sense of affiliation with commodities imported from faraway
colonies in the East. This stanza not only introduces the interior
scene of grandmother's Bow Lane shop in detail, but also implies a
colonial nostalgia through the social practices of tin tea boxes in
everyday life. For the second scene in the shop, the detailed
description of "black iron-flowered" weighing scales viewed through a
ten-year-old boy's eyes magnifies its scope on segments of realities
and fragments of memories. The poet's description of objects on the
counter, weighing scales and weights, seem to reconstruct the personal
account of childhood experiences and memories, looking at photographs,
shot by shot. Unlike those engravings in the earlier sequences, these
mimic-pictorial representations of weighing scales in the shop embody a
mechanical form of reproduction on the snapshot of moments lived in the
child-poet's recollections. For these arrangements and reconstructions
of memories, Grandmother, the shop owner, seemingly possessed the power
and administrated routines of chores in the shop and family life. Like
the antique scales, Grandmother stately weighs up a matter of life and
death, actively handling household and kinships. In general, the shop
is a thriving business and open to the public; however, this place is
more like an extensive space of family territory. Grandmother's shop is
closely connected with the whole family, consisting of reciprocal
relations and interactions among aunts and uncles in the house. This
shop-family house is both a public and private space, simultaneously
manifesting and concealing certain realities or truth in the
recollections of family history. This first impression of Grandmother
and her ownership of the shop-family house not only reconfirms the
established symbolic description of the mythic hag successively in
Kinsella's Notes from the Land of the Dead and the previous sequence
(John 239), but also suggests the criterion of signification,
experiences, and recollections derived from the tradition Grandmother
represented. From this opening narrative of Grandmother, the
autobiographical writing portrays the poet's family and then
characterizes these aunts and uncles in a caricature of tedious family
life. Like characters in Malton's engraving, depictions of aunts and
uncles represent different perspectives of family experiences in the
retrospection of personal history and in the introspection of the
subjectivity-formation.
With
a sense of humor, the poet sketches the practices of everyday life like
looking at the ludicrous moments in albums of family photographs. These
moments capture the transient aspects of personal memories and
metaphorically attempt to penetrate the interior subjectivity in the
movement of walking and the process of retrospection. While the poet
walks further into the interior of Grandmother's shop-family house, he
moves into a rather private and domestic part of subjectivity-the back
room. Unlike the front shop, this back room is an enclosed domestic
playground or even an inner sanctum for this child, who holds "with a
rolled-up newspaper," "killing flies" "at the holy pictures." The poet
depicts this moment of burlesque and perceives the project of
self-consciousness in front of holy pictures.
There
was one on the glass
on the Sacred Heart's face,
with the black little pointed head
and dead eyes
looking everywhere.
It kept twining and wiping its thin paws.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
and it disappeared, and started flying
up with the others around and around
at angles under the bulb. (BF75)
The
setting of this back room is like an inner sanctum, which ironically
and ambivalently plays a role as holy place as well as a secret chamber
in the family house. The picture of the "Sacred Heart" stately
represents a symbol of the Christian belief, like St. Catherine's
Church in Malton's engraving, or even ethically as a pervasive power of
dominance and surveillance over the public. Interestingly, the poet
contrasts the "black little pointed head," the insignificant creature
to the Sacred Heart's face. Rather than the discipline of Catholicism,
this tiny insect dominates the scene in the back room and intensively
intrigues the kid to follow. On the one hand, in front of the sacred
picture the fly with "dead eyes" "looking everywhere," which projects
from the reflection of the glass on the picture, exactly like a
burlesque surrogate of the omnipresent and omnipotent Supreme Being
extensively oversees and manipulates the examinees or the sinners of
moral life. On the other hand, flies are creatures for pleasure and
like Indian tin boxes and weighing scales treated as significant icons
in the personal account of childhood experiences. Through this scene of
killing flies, the religious convention rooted in Irish everyday life
or the disciplines of Catholicism on individual behavior is gradually
weakened and intensively confronted with the mundane affairs and those
ethically prohibited and consciously desired objects. From the
remembrance in the back room, the poet deviously initiates the speaking
subject in the sequence or the speaking persona-the autobiographic poet
in the stream of recollected fragments. This speaking subject referring
to the reciprocal position of the poet in the poetic formation embodies
the sense of self-consciousness and extends its relation to the social,
cultural, political space of everyday life; particularly socially
constructed is the subjectivity of the poet in the personal account of
family and childhood experience.
TOP
Memories of Childhood and Urban
Experience
Over a span of time, the poet continues to recollect his memories of
childhood through experiences of visiting cousins far away from
Grandmother's shop, and then initiates his adventures wandering in
streets and the riverbank. On the way to his cousins' houses, the scene
of childhood experiences unexpectedly becomes the unknown world of
memories that differ from the familiar places or streets where he
lives.
Up the bright road starting toward
Naas
with the line of new houses
going up the long hill
near the big white Chapel
with the two spires
towering up off the front wall
full of arches and holy figures and stone flowers
we
turned off into a hidden
street of brown houses
down to door in the quietest corner
to visit our best cousins (BF 76)
The route to visit his cousins
represents a recurring image of religious belief or the authority
intensively impressed in the childhood experience. Like the presence of
St. Catherine's Church and the picture of the Sacred Heart, "the big
white Chapel," "holy figures and stone flowers," though probably
belonging to architectures and decorations of streetscapes, still
suggests the immanent and pervasive significance of religion in
relation to practices of social and public space. On his way to the
cousin's house, the poet moves step by step toward the rural "country,"
on a pilgrimage to the wilderness in order to escape from the extensive
disciplines of Grandmother as well as Catholic conventions. Through
"the line of new houses" and "big white Chapel," the "hidden street of
brown houses" metaphorically leads to the adventure of the hidden,
unknown secret and implies the jouissance of prohibited desire in 'the
quietest corner' of childhood experience.
TOP
Adventure in the Darkness/ Wilderness
This temporary excursion to visit cousins in the countryside
significantly imitates the self-awareness and self-understanding of
subjectivity through ritualistic but prohibited frolic. The poet and
his cousins move to "the river brink" and wildly enjoy their leisure
time and outdoor activities among the rushes and the reeds. When it
turns into the dusk, the scene of wilderness temptingly intrigues these
children.
The
Night crept
among our chalk signs on the path
and trickled into the shores.
The
moon hung round and silver
out over the empty Bank
between the backs of the people's houses
where
we piled the rubbish up
on the clay in the dark
and set it on fire and talked into the flames
and skipped around in wickedness
with no mercy to the weak or the fat
or the witless or the half blind. (BF 77)
At
first, the poet depicts the setting of this dark meeting held at the
river brink in the moonlight. Accompanying with the Night and the moon,
the children's meeting in the wilderness constructs not only the sense
of enjoyment at the campfire but also a primitive ritual of flames. On
the one hand, the metaphor of the night and the moon here respectively
suggests the ritualization of forbidden behaviors that are not allowed
in common faithful Catholic families. The "empty Back" and "the backs
of the people's houses" assuredly indicate the secrecy and mystique of
this riverbank meeting, geographically faraway from the populous town
and metaphorically alienated from social conventions and ethics of
everyday life in the Catholic community. On the other hand, the shadow
of the darkness or "the Night" further implicates the poet's hideous
underworld, or the negative and excluded sphere of his autobiography,
which the speaking subject represents and intends to reveal.
Like
the "chalk sign on the path," the poet implicitly elicits the desire
from the oppressed unconsciousness embedded in the retrospection of
childhood. In spite of chitchats, curses, or grumbles, the speaking
subject consciously perceives the sensational ecstasy as well as the
immanent resistance in the enclosure of darkness.
I
have struggled, hand
over hand,
in the savage dance.
I
have lain inert, the flesh in the nightmare,
eating and eaten,
with eyes wide open. (BF77)
For the speaking subject in this
unusual experience, the "I" specifically demonstrates the existence of
self, the presence of a speaking subject in a confessional account of
autobiography. In the moonlight meeting, "the savage dance" and the
desperate attempt to "struggle" over the "nightmare" strongly suggest
both the practices of ethical disciplines and its counteraction of
sinful behaviors and thoughts. Accompanying with the flames, the savage
dance metaphorically implies the mystic rite of sexual self-recognition
through sensational experience of desire, the physical impulse to
devour imaginary representations of sexual body ("the balm a clouded
breast"), the temptation to whiff the olfactory pleasure of fragrance
("the musk of a stocking"). Like the speaker in "Nightwalker," the
speaking subject is conscious of the self's presence in the process of
recollection. However, more than the speaker in "Nightwalker," this
speaking subject specifically reifies the desire and the temptation of
sexuality from the unknown world of personal experience. Through
implications of sexual temptation, the poet implicitly recollects the
daring experience of the immature and the fascination of sexuality in
the context of Catholic ethics and family-life. In other words, the
particular experience of forbidden pleasure not only exposes the hidden
secret of autobiography, but also allows him to acknowledge the
subjectivity, the self-perception of his existence through
self-reflexive accounts of historical past and recollections. While
historical figures are characterized and discerned in the process of
multiple implications on previous engravings, these fragments of
personal memories, particularly for unusual or forbidden experiences,
also suggest the discontinuity and incredibility in the accounts of
personal history. Moreover, this process of recollection selectively is
written in part as personal history and then revisions of that account
that yet dislocate the perception of personal experiences and
self-understanding of subjectivity in the fragmentation of
retrospection.
However, these self-reflexive recollections do not merely emphasize on
the alluring desire of sexuality and self-conviction of immorality, but
rather intensively attempt to replenish fragments of the past and
meticulously to reiterate, to reconstruct, and to re-authenticate the
subjectivity of the I in the poem, or the poetic formation of a
provisional but fluid identity in the autobiographical account. This
movement between memories and self-consciousness, which discerns the
forbidden experience like an interpretation of a dream or nightmare,
implicitly varnishes over the authenticity of personal experience
underlying the speaking subject's words. This process of recollection
does not really reflect the past but further blurs the vision to
retrospect and to perceive truly realities in the personal history. For
the self-awareness, the recurring imaginary subject "she" (or
specifically the reification of the sexual desire from the "picture
book") obviously plays an important part in the psychical evolution and
also alludes to the influence or the temptation of female figures, like
Grandmother, hag, and the "femme fatale" in the picture book. For this
moment of peculiar experience, more or less the imaginary She occupies,
conducts and further moves the poet's mind in that "she was really
minding us." In other words, the speaking subject indirectly recognizes
himself and falsely authenticates his words by the identification of
She in the picture book. This identification with the She misplaces the
order of recollection and then transfers the hallucination to the
reality. Moreover, this transference from forbidden behaviors to the
repentance in the scene of the savage dance and flames leads to the
confessional account and to the candor of self. Before stopping at the
second hour of his walk, the speaking subject impressively announces
the confession and indirectly refers to the poet's autobiographical
statement in public as well as emerging in the account of memories.
I
know I was not bold
even if I did terrible things.
I was not a barefaced liar
or a thick-ah or a go-boy, or a pup
I never went with the cur next door
or those gets down the street.
I was always properly dressed,
and minded my brother.
One night we scrounged up together
and felt the little eggs in each other.
And I always remembered
who and what I am. (BF79)
The speaking subject's confession
characteristically expresses the intimate feelings and metaphoric
implications of the poetic formation. The speaking subject is both
psychological and metaphorical in these recollections. The confession
is a psychological evolution of experience, a displacement from these
forbidden behaviors in the wilderness to the reserved conduct in the
church. Like a confession in the church, these words in the context of
spatiotemporality admit those moments lived in the past, to recite
experiences of "terrible things," and to enunciate "who and what I am"
straight away. For the structure of this sequence, the verb tense
transfers to and fro the present and the past that assumes a process of
displacement, disillusion and in part self-identification, possibly
demonstrating latent memories and reclaiming the existence of the
progressive present in the poet's account of walks.
In the context, this confession intensively manifests the poet's
affinity with the town Dublin, the colloquial expression of language
and its urban subculture. For the local idiom, "thick-ah" (signify
'stupid') and "go-boy" (derived from "go-by-the-wall," meant 'a sly
person or hypocrite') suggests the transference from the standard to
the local, or rather the specific use of language in the
cultural/historical context. In addition, the pejorative expressions
"pup" and "gets" that respectively indicate an unpleasant lad and kids
"in the street" expressively depict its socio-political context of
local culture and tradition that further brings the poet close to the
living moment of his childhood memories, the sense of belonging with
his place and town. Moreover, the use of Dublin dialect in the
confession suggests returning to his roots, to the ground, and to the
self-position in life. Therefore, the conflation of colloquial
expression of daily language, practices of everyday life in the
memories, and retrospections of the past in both public and private
history constructs the trajectory of walking in a metaphorical
discourse of St. Catherine's Church, Thomas Street, and Dublin as well
as Kinsella's poetic formation through the speaking subject's
meticulous observations and self-scrutiny, untiring and perpetual
revisions of the past or going back to the beginning within historical
discourses, art works, poetic works, and autobiography.
TOP
|