"City Sights/Sites of Memories and Dreams"

[Lefebvre: The Production of Space]

Provider: Kate Liu / ¼B¬ö¶²

Lefebvre's triad --p. 6-7  space as process--as produced in inseparable, yet shifting physical and social contexts.  Lefebvre (1991) focuses attention on the production of space by, among other things, constructing a model of various "processes of assembly" (pp. 31-33).  These include "representations of space," "spatial practices," and "representational spaces."  The model tends to distinguish professional practices such as planning (representations of space) from spatial patterns of everyday life (spatial practices) from the symbolic meanings enacted in spatial form (representational spaces).

Combining time and space--p. 7   Helen Liggett suggests in Chapter 9 that the constitutive relations among various modes of assembly can be seen as modes of articulation or ways of making sense.  She relates the time/space of analysis to the time/space of social production through the creation of photographic images and narratives that re(enact) spatial patterns.

Helen Liggett "City Sights/Sites of Memories and Dreams"
introducing Lefebvre
p. 245  A unitary theory of space as process--By unitary he means applicable to all levels, .… By process, he means to see space as continually being produced.  In Lefebvre's thinking

Representational space   252 --process of assembly
Processes of assembly are dialectical, not discreet and oppositional.  . . .
The community is a representational space that encompasses the memory of a time and place, a fulfilling way of life and also a dream for the future.

Ligget's suggestion: 255
"Lefebvre's categories are the most powerful when they are used as tools of analysis, not applied as mutually exclusive categories to be sought out and observed.  To ask questions such as, "Is this representation of space or a spatial practice? . .  is to reduce their potential for the project of interpreting processes of assembly at work in the social/physical space.  Instead, and this is L's real gift to urbanists, the three categories are a beginning from which to analyze space as an activity and to ask questions about the dialectical relations in terms of which space is formulated and functions" (255)

imaginary geography

    Lefebvre is far from neutral observer of spatial conventions.  Against the fragmentation of a number of disciplines that place space in the service of external agenda, Lefebvre wants to recall the conditions of production.  This knowledge would, for him, "be expected to rediscover time (and in the first place the time of production) in and through space" (91).

p. 256  Barthes (1986)  "The City is a discourse" (p. 92)

    To move this statement from being merely metaphorical to being useful for analysis, he suggests conceptualizing the city in terms of signifying practices, the making and changing of meaning.  Space, then, does not stand for anything, it is the development, play and interchangeability of signification.  The city depends on memories, it requires dream; that is, aspects of life that representations of space exclude and some of what Lefebvre wishes to capture in his insistence on spatial practices and representational space are [sic: as] inseparable components of the dynamics of spatial production.



Source

Helen Liggett. "City Sights/Sites of Memories and Dreams."  Spatial Practices: Critical Explorations in Social/Spatial Theory.  Ed. Helen Liggett & David C. Perry.  London: Sage, 1995.

(external) Literary Criticism Databank: Postmodernism and Urban Space ;
Postmodern Theories and Texts
;
Postmodern Space, Postcolonial Resistance
  Spring, 1999