"The Nation Form"

Provider: Kate Liu / 劉紀雯
10/4, 96

Balibar, Etienne. "The Nation Form"-Review XIII 3 (Summer 1990): 329-61. 

purpose: to clarify...that of the causes and "deep" structures of contemporary racism. 

  1. 背景 Terminology: nation and state; social formation; world state-system; 
    Marxist historiography: functionalist (nation as instrument of bourgeois hegemony) and historicist (nation overdetermining class struggle) 
    ←→study national unity as an historical reality in fact divided because of antagonistic class strategies, or even as the long-term consequence of a continuous transformation of "class" identities and the unstable equilibria established between opposing interests 
    Althusser's influence: ISA as combined functioning of several dominant institutions (102) 
  2. 摘要 
    History: 
    1. Pre-history-on-linear, a series of conjunctural relations (e.g. institution of national language, development of monarchical power, centralization of legal and fiscal power, the complementariness of church and state ) 
    2. threshhold-nation and world economy-the concurrence of nationalism and cosmopolitanism 
    3. (delayed) nationlization of society-state bourgeoisie
    4. producing the people--institution of individuals as nationals-
      methods: education, force, analogy of religion, fictive ethnicity (every identity is individual, but socially produced) (only imaginary communities are real
      --unification of people by ideological form, e.g. patriotism, nationalism 
    5. fictive ethnicity and ideal nation-naturalization of belonging 
    6. the production of ethnicity through language and race-racialization of language, verbalization of race 
    7. family and school-the dissolution of extended family// penetrated by state-intervention (e.g. health care, census, birth control, eugenics) 
issues: 
  • language community (98) The linguistic community induces a terribly constraining ethnic memory? but it is one which none the less possess a strange plasticity: it immediately naturalizes new acquisitions. It does so too quickly in a sense....Ideally, it 'assimilates' anyone, but holds no one. 
  • The future of nation (p. 91; 105) in globalism 
  • topics for future discussion: fictive ethnicity, national history and language, different nation forms (U.S. vs. France, US vs. Canada, Canada vs. UK, etc.)

(external) Literary Criticism Databank: Postcolonialism